Pond Liner Types Compared: EPDM, RPE, PVC and Concrete

Last updated

The liner is the one part of a pond you cannot easily upgrade later without draining and rebuilding. Here is how the common options compare.

Quick comparison

LinerTypical material costStrengthsWatch-outsCommon use
EPDM rubber (often 45 mil)about $0.65 to $2.30 per sq ftvery flexible, fits complex shapes, easy to seam and patch, fish-safe versions widely usedheavier to handlemost residential koi ponds and water gardens
RPE (reinforced polyethylene)about $0.45 to $1.65 per sq ftlighter and strong for its weight, good for large pondsless forgiving to fold into tight shapeslarge ponds and lakes
PVClowlow upfront costshorter life, especially if exposed to sun; lower tear strengthbudget and small ponds
HDPE sheetabout $0.30 to $0.70 per sq ftinexpensive, weldablestiff, harder to fitlarge and agricultural ponds
Preformed shellabout $3.40 to $80 per sq ftrigid, quick to installfixed shape and sizesmall garden ponds
Concreteabout $63.50 to $113.50 per sq ftvery durable, any shapehighest cost, can crack, needs sealingformal ponds, natural pools

Why most pros use EPDM

For residential ponds, fish-safe EPDM over a protective underlayment is the most common choice. It stretches to fit boulders, shelves and waterfalls, and it can be seamed and patched in the field. Liner lifespan claims vary widely by manufacturer and by how much of the liner is exposed to sun, so ask your installer what warranty comes with the liner they use.

Don't skip the underlayment

Underlayment is a fabric layer under the liner that protects against rocks and roots. It is inexpensive insurance against punctures.

How much liner do you need?

A common rule of thumb:

  • Liner length = pond length + (2 × maximum depth) + 2 feet for overlap
  • Liner width = pond width + (2 × maximum depth) + 2 feet for overlap

Your builder will add extra for shelves, waterfalls and streams.

FAQ

Is PVC liner safe for fish?

Use liner sold as fish-safe. Some roofing and general-purpose sheets contain additives that are not intended for ponds.

Can a liner be repaired?

EPDM can usually be patched once the leak is found. See the pond leak guide.

Find a pond pro near you

Browse pond professionals by state or search the full Pond Pros directory.

Browse by location · Search the directory

Sources: Lawn Love and HomeServe liner cost data; Pond Trade Magazine liner comparisons. Prices vary by supplier and thickness.